Christmas Would You Rather Questions
These 101 Christmas would you rather questions are clean and all about the holidays, for a class party or Christmas dinner. Start with "Would you rather spend a whole day sledding or spend a whole day ice skating?" or "Would you rather have hot cocoa that never gets cold or have mittens that never get wet?"
They cover Santa, snow, trees, cookies, presents and family traditions, and many come with a follow-up question for whoever picks. A few are about school and a few about the office party, and the answers at the end of this page say which to skip for which group.
Would You Rather Questions is a free game from Couchful that plays in the browser with no signup. The Christmas set stays out of the everyday mix, so it only comes up when you pick it: the Play button on this page, the Christmas chip, or the Christmas deck in hot seat mode, where 2 to 10 players pass one phone and guess each other's picks.
101 questions, 41 with a follow-up to ask whoever picks.
Christmas Would You Rather Questions
Ten to start with
Would you rather have Christmas morning start at 5 a.m. with everyone excited or sleep in until noon and open presents after lunch?
Follow-up: What would you do first, at 5 a.m. or after lunch?
Would you rather be one of Santa's reindeer for a night or be one of Santa's elves for a whole year?
Follow-up: What would you do first as a reindeer or an elf?
Would you rather decorate the tree with only candy canes or decorate the tree with only popcorn garlands?
Follow-up: What else would you hang on the tree?
Would you rather get a handwritten letter back from Santa or get a photo of Santa leaving your house?
Follow-up: What would you ask Santa in your letter, or hope to see in the photo?
Would you rather have a snow globe that shows any place you name or have an advent calendar that holds a tiny surprise you choose each night?
Would you rather be stuck in a chimney for an hour or be tangled in the Christmas lights for an hour?
Follow-up: How would you get out of the chimney or the lights?
Would you rather wear jingle bells on your shoes all December or wear a light-up nose all December?
Would you rather have every song you hear be a Christmas carol for a year or never hear a Christmas carol again?
Follow-up: Which carol would you sing all year, or miss most of all?
Would you rather have it snow only on Christmas Day or have it snow every day from December 1 to New Year's Day?
Follow-up: What is the first thing you would do in the snow?
Would you rather ride in Santa's sleigh for one delivery night or drive a steam train full of kids to the North Pole?
Follow-up: Where would you stop first, in the sleigh or on the train?
Christmas would you rather questions, 11 to 101
Would you rather find the perfect gift for everyone in five minutes or have everyone find the perfect gift for you?
Follow-up: Who is the hardest person on your list to find a gift for?
Would you rather get a present a little too big to fit through the door or get a present so small you need a magnifying glass to find it?
Follow-up: What do you think is inside the big present or the tiny one?
Would you rather get one present you can open on December 1 or get three presents you cannot open until New Year's Day?
Would you rather make a snow angel the size of a house or have a snowball fight with one hundred people?
Follow-up: Where would you make the snow angel, or who joins the snowball fight?
Would you rather be the one who puts the star on top of the tree every year or be the one who plugs in the lights for the first time every year?
Would you rather eat Christmas dinner at a table made of ice or eat Christmas dinner in a treehouse covered in lights?
Would you rather spend Christmas Eve at the North Pole or spend Christmas Eve on a cruise ship?
Follow-up: Who would you bring to the North Pole or on the cruise?
Would you rather help Santa read every wish list or help Santa wrap every present?
Would you rather have a Christmas tree that sings when you walk past or have a doormat that tells a joke to every guest?
Would you rather be the fastest present wrapper in the world or be able to guess any gift before you open it?
Follow-up: Which gift would you love to wrap, or to guess?
Would you rather have hot cocoa that never gets cold or have mittens that never get wet?
Follow-up: Who would you share the cocoa with, or lend the mittens to?
Would you rather spend a whole day sledding or spend a whole day ice skating?
Follow-up: Who would you take sledding or ice skating?
Would you rather go caroling door to door in the snow or lead a carol sing-along on a stage?
Follow-up: Which carol would you sing first, at the door or on the stage?
Would you rather wear Santa's real coat for a day or wear Santa's real hat for a year?
Would you rather live in a town where it is Christmas every day or live in a town that skips Christmas but has two birthdays a year?
Would you rather have a gingerbread cookie that talks or have a candy cane that never gets smaller?
Follow-up: What would the cookie say, or what would you do with the candy cane?
Would you rather be in charge of the kids' table at Christmas dinner or be the only grown-up still sitting at the kids' table?
Follow-up: What game would you start at the kids' table?
Would you rather have a tree that grows a new ornament every night or have a wreath that whispers which present is yours?
Would you rather build the biggest snow fort on your street or build the tallest snowman on your street?
Follow-up: What would you name your snow fort or your snowman?
Would you rather get a sweater knit by Grandma every year or get a mystery gift from a secret relative every year?
Would you rather string ten thousand lights on your house or have one perfect wreath on your door?
Would you rather be in charge of the Christmas menu or be in charge of the Christmas music?
Follow-up: What would you put on the menu or the playlist first?
Would you rather have Christmas dinner with your favorite cartoon family or have Christmas dinner with your favorite sports team?
Follow-up: Who would you sit next to at dinner?
Would you rather leave cookies for Santa and catch him eating them or leave carrots for the reindeer and watch them crunch?
Follow-up: What would you say if you caught Santa or the reindeer?
Would you rather receive a present that is exactly what you asked for or receive a present you never thought to ask for?
Would you rather have a fireplace that crackles with a warm glow all winter or have heated floors in every room all winter?
Would you rather be snowed in with your family for three days or be snowed in with your best friends for three days?
Follow-up: What would you play while you were snowed in?
Would you rather get a sled that goes twice as fast or get a sled big enough for your whole family?
Follow-up: Where is the first hill you would take the sled?
Would you rather make cookies that taste like whatever you are thinking of or make cookies that make everyone who eats one laugh?
Would you rather know the words to every Christmas song or play every Christmas song on the piano?
Would you rather be the one who hands out every present or be the one who gets to open the very last present?
Would you rather be the narrator of the school holiday play or be the star of the school holiday play?
Would you rather open your presents in pajamas by the tree or open your presents outside in the snow?
Follow-up: Who would you want next to you, by the tree or in the snow?
Would you rather find reindeer hoof prints in the snow on Christmas morning or find a present with your name on it that nobody remembers buying?
Would you rather be your family's official Christmas photographer or be your street's official snowman judge?
Would you rather win the neighborhood decorating contest or win the family gingerbread house contest?
Follow-up: What would you make to win the contest?
Would you rather go to a holiday parade or be on a float in the holiday parade?
Follow-up: What would your float look like, or what would you hope rolls by?
Would you rather get coal in your stocking but it turns into a diamond or get a present that turns into anything you want, but only for a week?
Would you rather sleep under the Christmas tree on Christmas Eve or sleep in a tent in the backyard to watch for the sleigh?
Would you rather have a holiday sweater that plays music or have a holiday hat with a working snow globe on top?
Would you rather meet Mrs. Claus and learn her secret cookie recipe or meet the elf who keeps the naughty and nice list?
Would you rather only eat Christmas cookies for breakfast in December or eat Christmas dinner leftovers for lunch until they run out?
Would you rather write a letter to Santa that is ten pages long or send Santa a video message from your living room?
Would you rather have Santa visit your school or have Jack Frost visit your school and paint frost on every window?
Follow-up: What would you say to Santa or to Jack Frost?
Would you rather spend the holidays at a ski lodge with a hot tub in the snow or spend the holidays at Grandma's house with all your cousins?
Would you rather decorate a tree that is three stories tall or decorate a tiny tree that fits in your hand?
Follow-up: What would you hang on the three-story tree or the tiny one?
Would you rather make a snowman out of mashed potatoes or make a turkey out of snow?
Would you rather get an extra day off before Christmas or get an extra day off after New Year's Day?
Would you rather be the first to see the presents under the tree or be the last one down the stairs and see everyone's faces?
Would you rather star in a Christmas movie everyone watches every year or sing a Christmas song everyone sings every year?
Follow-up: What would your movie or your song be about?
Would you rather have ornaments that play a short movie of the day they were hung or have tinsel that changes color with your mood?
Would you rather get new pajamas to open every Christmas Eve or get a new book to open every Christmas Eve?
Follow-up: What pajamas or book would you hope to unwrap?
Would you rather see the town's lights from the top of a Ferris wheel or see the town's lights on a slow drive past every house?
Would you rather have Christmas Eve last twice as long or have Christmas Day last twice as long?
Would you rather have Santa's sleigh land in your backyard for five minutes or have the elves build one toy you design?
Follow-up: What would you design, or show Santa in your backyard?
Would you rather draw your boss's name in the office Secret Santa or have your boss draw your name?
Follow-up: What would you buy your boss, or hope your boss buys you?
Would you rather give a gift at the end of a treasure-hunt trail of clues or give a gift hidden inside ten boxes nested together?
Would you rather find out Santa's real address or find out how the reindeer really fly?
Follow-up: Who would you tell about Santa's address or the flying reindeer?
Would you rather cook Christmas dinner for twenty people or wash every dish after Christmas dinner for twenty people?
Would you rather have elves clean your room every night in December or have elves wrap every gift you give this year?
Would you rather celebrate Christmas the way a different country does every year or keep every one of your family's traditions exactly the same forever?
Would you rather get a letter from your future self every Christmas or send a present to your future self every Christmas?
Follow-up: What would you put in the gift or hope to read in the letter?
Would you rather help pick the family tree at a tree farm or help pick out the lights for the whole house?
Would you rather make paper snowflakes that fall from the ceiling or make paper chains that wrap around the whole house?
Would you rather spend Christmas Eve in a cozy library with a fireplace or spend Christmas Eve in a toy store after closing time?
Would you rather be a snowflake that floats down for an hour or be a twinkle light on the tallest tree in the world for a night?
Would you rather throw snowballs that always hit their target or never get hit by a snowball?
Follow-up: Who would you want on your team in a snowball fight?
Would you rather spend Christmas morning at a big family breakfast or spend Christmas morning on a quiet walk in the snow?
Would you rather sing a holiday song in front of the whole school or bake cookies for the whole school?
Would you rather wrap every present in the Sunday comics or wrap every present in plain brown paper you draw on yourself?
Would you rather have the Christmas lights stay up all year or take every light down the day after Christmas?
Would you rather watch the same Christmas movie with your family every year or watch a Christmas movie none of you has seen every year?
Follow-up: Which movie would you watch first?
Would you rather wear a loud holiday sweater every Friday in December or wear a Santa hat to every party in December?
Would you rather taste every cookie at a giant cookie swap or bring the cookie everyone asks the recipe for?
Would you rather find a magic ornament that grants one wish or find a magic stocking that grants three tiny wishes?
Follow-up: What would you wish for, one big wish or three tiny ones?
Would you rather build a gingerbread copy of your own house or build a gingerbread copy of a famous castle?
Would you rather ride a sleigh pulled by horses through the snow or ride a dog sled across a frozen lake?
Would you rather spend Christmas Eve telling family stories or spend Christmas Eve playing board games?
Would you rather give every kid in your town one present or give one kid every present on their list?
Follow-up: Which kid would you pick, or what would every kid get?
Would you rather receive a mystery ornament from a stranger every year or hide a mystery ornament on the tree in the town square every year?
Would you rather have every card you write make someone laugh out loud or have every card you write make someone cry happy tears?
Would you rather get a holiday card from every country in the world or get a holiday card from every person in your town?
Would you rather be in charge of the office Secret Santa or be in charge of decorating the office?
Would you rather finish all your holiday shopping by Halloween or do all your holiday shopping on Christmas Eve?
Follow-up: What would you buy first, before Halloween or on Christmas Eve?
Would you rather have every relative bring a dish nobody asked for or have every relative bring the exact same dish?
Would you rather have the office party at a bowling alley or have the office party at an escape room?
Follow-up: Who at the office would win?
Would you rather keep every gift in the exchange under five dollars or make every gift in the exchange yourself?
Would you rather have a snow day the week before Christmas or have a holiday pancake breakfast every Sunday in December?
Would you rather host a cookie-decorating party for your whole street or leave a plate of cookies at every door on your street?
Would you rather give a two-minute toast at the holiday party or lead the first game at the holiday party?
Would you rather return every gift you do not love or keep every gift and never regift one?
How to play would you rather at a Christmas party
- Play while the cookies bake. Read one each time the oven timer goes off, or ten in a row while everyone waits for dinner.
- Walk to your answer. With kids, the tree side of the room is A and the door side is B. Everyone walks to their pick, then one person from each side says why.
- Guess what Grandpa picks. In hot seat mode with the Christmas deck, the family guesses what the person in the seat will pick before they reveal it.
- Warm up a gift exchange. Ask three questions while people find a seat, before the white elephant swap or the left right story starts.
Questions people ask
What are some Christmas would you rather questions?
Some are silly and some are about giving: "Would you rather make a snowman out of mashed potatoes or make a turkey out of snow?", "Would you rather wear jingle bells on your shoes all December or wear a light-up nose all December?" and "Would you rather give every kid in your town one present or give one kid every present on their list?" For a funny round, ask whoever picks to act out their answer.
Are these Christmas would you rather questions good for kids and family?
Yes. All of them are clean and about the holidays, so they suit kids from about age 5 and a family table. For the family, try "Would you rather spend Christmas Eve telling family stories or spend Christmas Eve playing board games?" and "Would you rather celebrate Christmas the way a different country does every year or keep every one of your family's traditions exactly the same forever?" Skip the few about the office, and read aloud for younger kids.
Which Christmas would you rather questions work for adults or an office party?
Some are written for grown-ups: hosting, gift exchanges, holiday shopping and the office party itself, like "Would you rather draw your boss's name in the office Secret Santa or have your boss draw your name?" Skip the few about school. At work, two or three with a show of hands take about five minutes.
How long does a round take at a Christmas party?
Ten in a row take about ten minutes with reasons, which fills the wait for dinner. In hot seat each turn takes a minute or two, so six relatives with one turn each take about ten minutes.
Can I print these for a class party?
Yes. The Print button prints all 101 as a numbered list without the game or the menus. Print one copy for whoever reads aloud, and cross out the few about the office first.
The rules in one line: one person asks, everyone picks one of the two options, and each player says why. How to play would you rather
Rather play than read? The game deals ten of these, one at a time, and never repeats one until you have seen the whole list.
Play 10 of theseMore would you rather questions
- Funny Would You Rather Questions100 questionsGoat laughs, clown shoes and a very fast chicken.
- Would You Rather Questions for Kids104 questionsPet unicorns, candy rain and a dog that can do math.
- Would You Rather Questions for Adults (Clean)81 questionsMoney, careers, homes and the choices grown-ups argue about.
- Funny Would You Rather Questions for Adults57 questionsBosses, in-laws, HOA letters and knees that predict the rain.
- Would You Rather Questions for Couples103 questionsDate nights, anniversaries and who plans the trip.
- Would You Rather Questions for Work77 questionsWork-safe icebreakers for meetings and team calls.
- Deep Would You Rather Questions79 questionsMemory, time, truth and the big what-ifs.
- Food Would You Rather Questions41 questionsBlue food, pickle sandwiches and a fried cricket.
- Superpower Would You Rather Questions41 questionsPower against power, magic pets and fantasy worlds.
- Valentine's Day Would You Rather Questions87 questionsPink snow, candy hearts that tell jokes and a hamster that delivers your valentines.