Herd Mentality

Rules · about 20 minutes · 3–20 players

Herd Mentality Rules

In Herd Mentality, everyone answers the same question in secret and wins a cow for writing the most common answer. If exactly one player writes something nobody else did, they take the Odd One Out card and cannot win while holding it. First to eight cows without that card wins; bigger groups can play to fewer.

Below are the complete rules, including the two situations most groups argue about: majority ties and when the Odd One Out card actually moves.

Play Herd Mentality online

What you need

Three to twenty players and one phone, or a phone each in an online room. On paper, everyone needs something to write on that the others cannot see, and you can print the question cards, a score sheet and a card to mark the odd one out. Games run about 20 minutes.

The aim

Reach the target, which is eight cows in the standard game. You win a cow by writing the same answer as most of the group. You are not trying to be clever, funny or right; you are trying to be average. That inversion is the entire game.

Playing a round

  1. Read the question. One person reads it aloud so everybody hears the same wording.
  2. Answer in secret. Everyone writes one answer. No discussion, no hints, no faces.
  3. Reveal together. All answers come out at once.
  4. Award cows. Everyone who wrote the most common answer takes a cow.
  5. Pass the Odd One Out card. If exactly one player wrote something nobody else did, they take it.

The Odd One Out card

The Odd One Out card is a lock, not a penalty, and the boxed game calls it the Pink Cow. You keep collecting cows while holding it, but you cannot win. It only moves when there is exactly one odd answer. If two or more players are each alone, nobody is the odd one out and the card stays put. Get rid of it by being ordinary again while somebody else is not.

Winning

The first player to the target without the Odd One Out card wins immediately. Bigger groups share out fewer cows, so this site suggests eight cows for up to five players, six for up to nine and four for ten or more. You can change the target before you start.

Edge cases

Small and large groups

The official game needs at least 4 players; this version allows 3. With two, you either both match and both score or neither does, so nobody can ever pull ahead. With three, most rounds are two against one, so the Odd One Out card moves often. With ten or more, the majority gets genuinely hard to read, and questions with fewer obvious answers ("name a color of the rainbow") play better than open ones.

To run the game yourself, start with the easy Herd Mentality questions in the Classic pack, or browse all 507 questions.

Herd Mentality rules FAQ

How do you play Herd Mentality?
Everyone answers the same question in secret. Reveal together: whoever wrote the most common answer wins a cow. If exactly one player is the odd one out, they are stuck with the Odd One Out card. First to the target wins, but you cannot win while holding it. The standard target is eight cows, and this version suggests fewer for bigger groups.
What happens if there is a tie for the majority answer?
The official rules say an even split scores nobody and nobody takes the Odd One Out card, and that is what happens here. When the biggest answer is tied but someone answered something else (like 2, 2 and 1), every tied group scores. The reveal screen always shows exactly which answers scored.
When does the Odd One Out card move?
Only when exactly one player gave a unique answer. If two or more players are each on their own, nobody is the odd one out and the Odd One Out card stays where it is.
How many players do you need for Herd Mentality?
The official game needs at least 4 players; this version allows 3. With two, you either both match and both score or neither does, so nobody can pull ahead. It comes alive at 4 or more, when there are enough people for a real majority to form. This version supports up to 20.