Unofficial fan version · 507 questions · 8 packs · free to copy
All Herd Mentality Questions, by Pack
This unofficial list has 507 Herd Mentality questions in 8 packs, with a sample of each pack and who it suits, from families and classrooms to teams and holiday tables. For 3 to 20 players, read them out, print them or download all 507 as a free PDF. A game to eight cows takes about 20 minutes.
Classic questions
100 questions for everyone, ages 10+. Easy everyday prompts with one answer most people land on. A good first game.
- Name a yellow food.
- Name a farm animal.
- Pick a pet: dog, cat, goldfish or rabbit?
Family questions
81 questions for ages 6+, families and classrooms. Kid-friendly questions with no reading traps, built for mixed-age tables and classrooms.
- Name an animal with stripes.
- Name a superhero.
- Pick a playing card: ace, king, queen or jack?
Adults questions
70 questions for ages 16+, game nights and house parties. Sharper, more opinionated prompts for grown-up game nights — no explicit content, just questions with more bite.
- Name a superpower most people would choose.
- Name something that tastes better at 2 a.m.
- Pick a seat on a plane: window, aisle or middle?
Office questions
58 questions for teams, icebreakers and offsites. Safe-for-work prompts for team icebreakers, standups and offsites. Nothing anyone has to think twice about answering.
- Name a corporate buzzword.
- Name something always found in an office kitchen.
- Pick where to work: office, home, coffee shop or beach?
Thanksgiving questions
34 questions for all ages, Thanksgiving dinners and Friendsgivings. Questions for the Thanksgiving table, from the side dishes to the nap on the couch, most with a favorite answer the whole family can guess, and some that will split it.
- Name a topping on sweet potato casserole.
- Name a pie people eat at Thanksgiving.
- Pick a side: stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans or cranberry sauce?
All 34 Thanksgiving questions →
Christmas questions
100 questions for all ages, festive parties and family gatherings. Festive questions for Christmas parties and family gatherings, each with a favorite answer the whole table can guess.
- Pick a Christmas movie: Elf, Home Alone, The Grinch or Die Hard?
- Name a famous snowman.
- Name a Christmas carol.
New Year's Eve questions
34 questions for all ages, New Year's Eve parties and family nights. Countdown questions for New Year's Eve parties and family nights, from midnight toasts to resolutions nobody keeps. Every one has a favorite answer the room can guess.
- Name something people throw at midnight.
- Name a food people give up in January.
- Name a drink people toast with at midnight.
All 34 New Year's Eve questions →
Super Bowl questions
30 questions for all ages, watch parties and game-day gatherings. Questions for a Super Bowl watch party, from the wings and the dip to the commercials and halftime, with a few easy ones about the game itself. Most have an answer the whole couch can guess.
- Name a food people eat at a Super Bowl party.
- Name a topping on nachos.
- Pick what you come for: the game, the commercials, the halftime show or the food?
Couchful is an independent site, not affiliated with or endorsed by the NFL. Super Bowl is a trademark of the NFL.
What makes a good Herd Mentality question?
A question needs a wide field of plausible answers and one that most people will land on anyway. "Name a farm animal" works because there are dozens of right answers and one everybody thinks of first. "Name a country" is too wide — the group scatters and nobody scores. "Name a primary color" is too narrow — everyone matches and the round is dead.
- Aim for questions with roughly 5–20 realistic answers, or a quick either/or ("Cats or dogs?") where a 4–1 split hands someone the Odd One Out card.
- Avoid anything with a single correct answer; that is trivia, not this.
- Avoid anything so personal that matching is impossible.
- Opinion questions are great for adults and terrible for mixed ages.
Herd Mentality questions FAQ
- How many Herd Mentality questions are there here?
- There are 507 questions in 8 packs: Classic (100), Family (81), Adults (70), Office (58), Thanksgiving (34), Christmas (100), New Year's Eve (34), Super Bowl (30). No question appears in two packs.
- Which pack should we start with?
- Start with Classic if you are not sure, since it is the pack the game picks when nobody chooses one. Choose Family for ages 6 and up, Adults for ages 16 and up, and Office for a team. The Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year’s Eve and Super Bowl packs are for those days.
- Are these the official Herd Mentality questions?
- No. These are unofficial, fan-made questions and they do not come from the boxed game. Big Potato Games makes that game. It is not affiliated with Couchful and has not endorsed these lists.
- Can we use these questions without a phone?
- Yes. Read a question out, have everyone write an answer in secret, then reveal together. The printable set has every question as a cut-out card, with a score sheet and an Odd One Out card, and the rules page covers scoring and ties.
- Can we add our own questions?
- Yes, when you play in the browser. Open “Add your own questions” under the question pack and type one per line. The game deals them first, then the pack carries on.