Unofficial fan version · 100 questions · All ages, festive parties and family gatherings
Christmas Herd Mentality Questions
This unofficial list has 100 Herd Mentality questions about Christmas, from movies and songs to stockings, the tree and the Nativity. It suits all ages at festive parties and family gatherings, with 3 to 20 players. A game to eight cows takes about 20 minutes, and a game to four cows fits dessert.
Updated
Ten to start with
- Pick a Christmas movie: Elf, Home Alone, The Grinch or Die Hard?
- Name a famous snowman.
- Name a Christmas carol.
- Name something you leave out for Santa.
- Pick a Christmas song: Jingle Bells, Silent Night, Last Christmas or Feliz Navidad?
- Name a meat served at Christmas dinner.
- Name something you eat at Christmas dinner.
- Name something you hang on a Christmas tree.
- Name something you put on top of a Christmas tree.
- Name a store people shop at for Christmas.
The other 90 Christmas questions
- Name a present children hope for.
- Pick your Christmas lights: white, colored, blinking or none?
- Name a Christmas dessert.
- Name something red and white at Christmas.
- Name a shape of Christmas cookie.
- Pick an Advent calendar door from 1 to 24.
- Name something you find in a Christmas stocking.
- Name a festive drink.
- Gifts: wrapped or bagged?
- Pick a Christmas disaster: burned turkey, dead batteries, family fight or broken toy?
- Pick a Christmas character: Grinch, Scrooge, Rudolph or Frosty?
- Name a color of wrapping paper.
- Name a Christmas cookie.
- Name something that lights up at Christmas.
- Name a vegetable on a Christmas plate.
- Name something Santa carries.
- Name something you see in a snow globe.
- Name a game people play at Christmas.
- Name something you see in a Nativity scene.
- Pick a month to put up the tree.
- Name a smell of Christmas.
- Name something you need to wrap a present.
- Pick a Christmas party game: Secret Santa, charades, karaoke or bingo?
- Pick a last-minute present: gift card, socks, chocolate or cash?
- Name a Christmas color.
- Name a sound you hear at Christmas.
- Name a singer famous for a Christmas song.
- Pick the worst Christmas job: dishes, carving, wrapping or hosting?
- Name a place people go on Christmas Day.
- Name a character from A Christmas Carol.
- Name a word you see on Christmas cards.
- Pick why Santa is late: snow, traffic, reindeer or cookies?
- Name something on a gingerbread house.
- Name something you add to hot chocolate.
- Name one of Santa's reindeer.
- Pick a Christmas tree: real, fake or none?
- Name a pattern on Christmas pajamas.
- Name a Christmas candy.
- Name something Santa says.
- Pick what time kids wake up on Christmas: 5, 6, 7 or 8?
- Name a Christmas toy that needs batteries.
- Name something you hang over the fireplace at Christmas.
- Name a cartoon character with a Christmas special.
- How many gifts should Santa bring one child?
- Name a gift the wise men brought.
- Name a gift from The Twelve Days of Christmas.
- Name a famous elf.
- Pick a Christmas Eve dinner: ham, lasagna, fish or takeout?
- Name a Christmas movie set in New York.
- Name something that goes missing every Christmas.
- Name something you eat on Christmas morning.
- Pick a cookie job: baking, decorating, eating or cleaning up?
- Name something you put on a Christmas wreath.
- Name a topping for Christmas cookies.
- Name a spice in gingerbread.
- Pick the first bite of a gingerbread house: roof, door, walls or candy?
- Name something on an ugly Christmas sweater.
- Name something Santa wears.
- Name a Christmas word that starts with S.
- Pick when to open presents: Christmas Eve, Christmas morning or Christmas afternoon?
- Name something you see at a Christmas parade.
- Name a Christmas movie with Santa in it.
- Name a character from How the Grinch Stole Christmas.
- Pick a Christmas Day outfit: pajamas, a sweater, dress clothes or something new?
- Name a character from Home Alone.
- Name a famous Christmas tree.
- Name a country famous for Christmas markets.
- Pick when Christmas music should start: November 1, Thanksgiving, December 1 or Christmas Eve?
- Name a place you hide presents.
- Name something people return after Christmas.
- Rate fruitcake from 1 to 10.
- Name a Christmas song you are tired of hearing.
- Name a room where the Christmas tree goes.
- Name something that comes in a Christmas tin.
- How many Christmas cookies is too many in one day?
- Name something green at Christmas.
- Name something that breaks on Christmas Day.
- Pick a Secret Santa budget: $10, $20, $25 or $50?
- Name something you buy on Christmas Eve.
- Name a Christmas song with a name in the title.
- Name someone who visits on Christmas Day.
- Pick the present to open first: biggest, smallest, shiniest or from Grandma?
- Name something Mrs. Claus bakes.
- Name a sport people watch on Christmas Day.
- Pick an elf job: making toys, wrapping, feeding reindeer or checking the list?
- Name a Christmas decoration you put outside.
- Name something you bring to a Christmas party.
- Pick a part in the Nativity play: Mary, Joseph, a shepherd or a sheep?
- Name something at the North Pole.
- Name a character from The Nutcracker.
A game for the slow part of Christmas
The Christmas pack fits the stretch after dinner, when everyone is still at the table and nobody wants to move. The questions stay on Christmas, from movies and songs to stockings, the tree and the Nativity, and all of them suit children and grandparents playing together. One phone passed around the table is enough, and relatives who are somewhere else can join an online room from their own phones.
Shared traditions herd, family habits split
Christmas has plenty of shared answers, which tends to make for quick herds. “Name a meat served at Christmas dinner” will probably pull most people toward turkey, and “Name something you leave out for Santa” toward cookies. The questions most likely to split a family are the ones where each household has its own habit. “Pick your Christmas lights: white, colored, blinking or none?” and “Pick a month to put up the tree” can divide the table along family lines, which is half the reason to play them with relatives. “Pick a Christmas movie: Elf, Home Alone, The Grinch or Die Hard?” sits in between, and it starts an argument about Die Hard.
A plan for Christmas evening
Start with a short game to four cows while dessert goes round, then play a full game to eight once the table is cleared. Before the second game, open “Add your own questions” and let each person write one about the family, such as what Grandpa will fall asleep watching. The game deals your own questions before the pack, so the family ones come up first, and the Christmas questions carry on after them.
Scoring and ties are in our Herd Mentality rules. To play from paper, the printable set has every pack as cut-out cards with a score sheet. This pack is also on pages 48–60 of the questions PDF. To print only this pack, download the Christmas pack PDF (16 US Letter pages, 18 KB), with its own rules page, score sheet and Odd One Out card.
Planning the whole party? Christmas party games sorted by group, with ready-made lineups.
For a church party or Sunday school, read the Nativity left right story aloud for the gift swap, then try the Christmas Bible trivia.
For a quiz, try the Christmas movie trivia, Santa trivia or Christmas trivia for kids, each with an answer key, to print or play. For one phone passed around, try the Christmas This or That questions or the Christmas would you rather questions.
Christmas questions FAQ
- Do the Christmas questions suit children?
- Yes. They stay on Christmas, with questions like “Name a famous snowman” and “Name something you leave out for Santa”, and they suit children and grandparents playing together.
- Can we add questions about our own family?
- Yes. Open “Add your own questions” and type one per line, such as what Grandpa will fall asleep watching. The game deals your questions first, then the Christmas questions carry on.
- Which Christmas questions split a family?
- The ones where each household has its own habit: “Gifts: wrapped or bagged?”, “Pick your Christmas lights: white, colored, blinking or none?” and “Pick a month to put up the tree”. An even split on a two-way question scores nobody.
- How many cows should we play to on Christmas?
- Try four for a short game while dessert goes around, then the standard eight once the table is cleared. Eight takes about 20 minutes. You set the target before the game starts.
- Is there a Christmas Herd Mentality questions PDF?
- Yes. The Christmas pack has its own free PDF of 16 US Letter pages: the paper rules on page 1, then every Christmas question as a cut-out card, a score sheet and an Odd One Out card. There is no official answer key, since the answer that scores is whatever most of your table writes.
Other packs
- Classic — everyone, ages 10+
- Family — ages 6+, families and classrooms
- Adults — ages 16+, game nights and house parties
- Office — teams, icebreakers and offsites
- Thanksgiving — all ages, Thanksgiving dinners and Friendsgivings
- New Year's Eve — all ages, New Year's Eve parties and family nights
- Super Bowl — all ages, watch parties and game-day gatherings