Herd Mentality

Unofficial fan version · 34 questions · All ages, Thanksgiving dinners and Friendsgivings

Thanksgiving Herd Mentality Questions

This unofficial list has 34 Herd Mentality questions about Thanksgiving: the food, the parade, the football, the leftovers and the nap. It suits all ages at Thanksgiving dinners and Friendsgivings, with 3 to 20 players. A game to eight cows takes about 20 minutes, and four or six cows fits the wait before dinner.

Play Herd Mentality online

Ten to start with

  1. Name a topping on sweet potato casserole.
  2. Name a pie people eat at Thanksgiving.
  3. Pick a side: stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans or cranberry sauce?
  4. Name something you put on mashed potatoes.
  5. Name something people watch on TV on Thanksgiving.
  6. Pick what you're most thankful for: family, friends, health or food?
  7. Name something that goes in stuffing.
  8. Name a part of the turkey people fight over.
  9. Pick a dish that comes store-bought: rolls, pie, cranberry sauce or stuffing?
  10. Name something people loosen after Thanksgiving dinner.

The other 24 Thanksgiving questions

  1. Name a place people nap after Thanksgiving dinner.
  2. Name a kitchen tool you only use at Thanksgiving.
  3. Pick a reason to be late to dinner: traffic, cooking, football or oversleeping?
  4. Name a vegetable that ends up left over at Thanksgiving.
  5. Name a Thanksgiving leftover you eat the next day.
  6. Name a city famous for its Thanksgiving parade.
  7. Pick a job for kids on Thanksgiving: set the table, fold napkins or wash dishes?
  8. Name something people buy on Black Friday.
  9. Name a spice in pumpkin pie.
  10. Name something kids make at school for Thanksgiving.
  11. Name a balloon character from a Thanksgiving parade.
  12. Name something served with pumpkin pie.
  13. Pick a Thanksgiving tradition: football, parade, naps or wishbone?
  14. Name a Thanksgiving food that comes in a can.
  15. Pick a Thanksgiving morning: parade, cooking, turkey trot or sleeping in?
  16. Name something guests bring for the host.
  17. Pick what happens before the meal: grace, toast, photo or nothing?
  18. Name something people bring when they're told to just bring themselves.
  19. Name a Thanksgiving movie or TV special.
  20. Name a meat people serve instead of turkey.
  21. Pick a number of hours to cook a turkey.
  22. Name something that gets burned on Thanksgiving.
  23. Pick the day after Thanksgiving: shopping, leftovers, couch or decorating?
  24. Name something you find on a Thanksgiving table besides food.

A game for the wait before dinner

The Thanksgiving pack is about the day itself: the food, the parade, the football, the leftovers and the nap. Everyone knows what a Thanksgiving table looks like, so a grandparent, a teenager and a guest from out of town can all join in. It fits the hour while the turkey rests, when the whole family is in one room and nobody is allowed near the kitchen.

Food answers herd, family answers scatter

Questions about the meal tend to have one answer most people reach straight away. “Name a pie people eat at Thanksgiving” will probably point most of the table at pumpkin, “Name a Thanksgiving food that comes in a can” at cranberry sauce, and “Name something you put on mashed potatoes” at gravy or butter. The questions most likely to split a family are the ones about habits, where every household does it differently. “Pick a Thanksgiving morning: parade, cooking, turkey trot or sleeping in?” can divide the table, and an even split scores nobody.

House rules for a family table

Play to four or six cows so a game ends before the food is served, then play a second one after the pie. Pair a young child with an older relative as one player, so they agree on one answer and share one score. If a question touches something your family would rather not get into, skip it before anyone answers; the question screen has a button for that. To include relatives who aren't there, start an online room instead, and everyone, in the room or not, joins with the code.

Scoring and ties are in our Herd Mentality rules. To play from paper, the printable set has every pack as cut-out cards with a score sheet. This pack is also on pages 43–47 of the questions PDF.

Planning the whole day? Thanksgiving games for family, adults and kids, from the parade to the pie.

For a quicker game at the table, try the Thanksgiving This or That questions, one phone for up to ten players, or read the Thanksgiving left right story aloud once the plates are cleared. For a quiz, the Thanksgiving trivia questions come with answers, to print or play.

Thanksgiving questions FAQ

What do the Thanksgiving questions ask about?
The day itself, with questions like “Name a pie people eat at Thanksgiving”, “Name a Thanksgiving food that comes in a can” and “Pick a Thanksgiving tradition: football, parade, naps or wishbone?”. A guest from out of town can join in, since everyone knows what the table looks like.
When in the day should we play?
The hour while the turkey rests suits it, when the family is in one room. Play to four or six cows so the game ends before the food is served, then play a second one after the pie.
Can relatives who are not with us play?
Yes. Start an online room instead of passing a phone. Everyone joins with the code on their own phone, whether they are at the table or somewhere else.
How can young children play at the Thanksgiving table?
Pair a young child with an older relative as one player, so they agree on one answer and share one score. If a question touches something your family would rather not get into, skip it before anyone answers.

Other packs