Herd Mentality

Unofficial fan version · 34 questions · All ages, New Year's Eve parties and family nights

New Year's Eve Herd Mentality Questions

This unofficial list has 34 Herd Mentality questions about New Year’s Eve, from the party and the countdown to the toast and the morning after. It suits all ages at parties and family nights, with 3 to 20 players. A game to eight cows takes about 20 minutes, so it fits the hour before midnight.

Play Herd Mentality online

Ten to start with

  1. Name something people throw at midnight.
  2. Name a food people give up in January.
  3. Name a drink people toast with at midnight.
  4. Name a city famous for its New Year's Eve party.
  5. Name a song people sing at New Year's.
  6. Name something you clink at midnight.
  7. Name something that sparkles at a New Year's party.
  8. Pick a New Year's Eve: big party, small party, night in or asleep by ten?
  9. Name a color of fireworks.
  10. Name the month people quit the gym.

The other 24 New Year's Eve questions

  1. Name a snack at a New Year's Eve party.
  2. Name something you blow into at midnight to make noise.
  3. Pick a reason to stay home on New Year's Eve: cold, crowds, cost or bedtime?
  4. Pick a New Year's Eve bedtime: 10 p.m., midnight, 1 a.m. or 2 a.m.?
  5. Pick a New Year's Day: football, brunch, cleaning or sleeping in?
  6. Name an app people delete in January.
  7. Name a person you text at midnight.
  8. Pick a word for the new year: fresh, hope, change or tired?
  9. Name something you write down at New Year's.
  10. Name a workout class people try in January.
  11. Name something people spill at a party.
  12. Name something you clean up on New Year's Day.
  13. Name a host of a New Year's Eve countdown show.
  14. Name something you take down after the holidays.
  15. Name something people save up for.
  16. Name something you light at a New Year's Eve party.
  17. Name something people wear on their head at a New Year's party.
  18. Name a party game for New Year's Eve.
  19. Name a place that's packed the first week of January.
  20. Pick the minute after midnight: kiss, toast, hug or text?
  21. Pick a New Year's Eve outfit: sparkles, black, pajamas or suit?
  22. Pick January 2: work, gym, couch or diet?
  23. Pick a promise for January: less phone, less sugar, more gym or more sleep?
  24. Pick the first app after midnight: texts, Instagram, TikTok or camera?

Playing toward midnight

The New Year's Eve pack covers the whole night, from the party and the countdown to the toast and the morning after. Many of the questions are about midnight, so they work well in the hour before it, while the room is waiting for the countdown anyway. Nothing in the pack needs anyone to stay up, though, so it also suits a family night that finishes at nine.

Midnight answers herd, resolutions spread out

Party questions tend to have answers most people reach straight away. “Name a drink people toast with at midnight” will probably point most people at champagne, and “Name something people throw at midnight” at confetti. “Pick a New Year's Eve bedtime: 10 p.m., midnight, 1 a.m. or 2 a.m.?” splits the room by age; “midnight” and “12” count as one answer. Questions about the year ahead tend to spread out more: “Pick a promise for January: less phone, less sugar, more gym or more sleep?” and “Name something people save up for” can go several ways, so a round can end with nobody scoring. “Name a person you text at midnight” depends on who is in the room.

A plan for the last hour of the year

Start a game to eight cows around 11 p.m. and agree a house rule before the first question: if nobody has reached the target by midnight, whoever has the most cows when the countdown starts wins, and a tie goes to one more question after the toast. The game itself keeps going until someone reaches the target, so the clock rule is yours to keep. For a family night that ends early, play to four cows and use the same rule at bedtime.

Scoring and ties are in our Herd Mentality rules. To play from paper, the printable set has every pack as cut-out cards with a score sheet. This pack is also on pages 61–65 of the questions PDF.

Planning the whole party? New Year’s Eve games for adults, families and kids, with a 9 p.m. to midnight lineup.

For one phone passed around, try the New Year’s This or That questions, or read the New Year’s Eve left right story aloud from about 11:55, so its last ten passes are the countdown.

New Year's Eve questions FAQ

When should we start so a game ends by midnight?
Start around 11 p.m. and agree a house rule first: if nobody has reached the target by midnight, whoever has the most cows when the countdown starts wins. The game itself keeps going until someone reaches the target, so the clock rule is yours to keep.
Do the New Year’s Eve questions suit a family night?
Yes. Many are about midnight, but nothing in the pack needs anyone to stay up. For a family night that ends early, play to four cows and use bedtime as the deadline.
Does “10 p.m.” count as the same answer as “10”?
Yes. On “Pick a New Year's Eve bedtime: 10 p.m., midnight, 1 a.m. or 2 a.m.?”, the game treats “10 p.m.”, “ten” and “10” as one answer. Capitals and plurals are folded together too, and the reveal screen lets you merge anything else that means the same thing.
Why can a round end with no cows?
Some questions have many fair answers. “Name a person you text at midnight” can go to a partner, a close friend, a parent or a sibling, so a round can end with nobody matching anyone. That scores no cows and leaves the Odd One Out card where it is.

Other packs