Herd Mentality

507 cards · score sheet · Odd One Out card

Printable Herd Mentality Questions

All 507 unofficial Herd Mentality questions from 8 packs as cut-out cards, with a score sheet and an Odd One Out card, to print here or download as one free PDF. For 3 to 20 players playing on paper; a game to eight cows takes about 20 minutes.

Updated

Download the PDF Play Herd Mentality online

Printing the cards

The cards print eight to a page on A4 or US Letter, two across and four down, and each pack starts on a new page. Everything prints black on white, so any printer will do. Each card has its pack name in the top corner, which makes a shuffled pile easy to sort back into packs. Card stock lasts longer than paper if you will play with the set again. To print a single pack, open it from the question lists and use "Print this pack".

Herd Mentality questions PDF

The same set is a ready-made PDF: download the Herd Mentality questions PDF (71 US Letter pages, 68 KB). Page 1 lists where each pack starts, so you can print only the packs you want, and it carries the paper rules below. To get A4 instead, press "Print these cards" on this page and choose "Save as PDF" as the printer.

How to play on paper

  1. Cut along the dashed lines and shuffle the cards face down. Mix all the packs, or keep to one for the night.
  2. Give everyone a pen and some paper, and print the score sheet or draw one.
  3. One person reads a card out. Everyone writes an answer in secret, then you all reveal together.
  4. Everyone who wrote the most common answer ticks a cow on the score sheet.
  5. If exactly one player wrote an answer nobody else did, they take the Odd One Out card. Nobody can win while holding it.
  6. First to eight cows wins.

With no screen to decide whether "dog" and "dogs" match, agree before the first card that the reader makes that call. Our Herd Mentality rules cover ties and the other arguments.

What the herd usually answers

There is no official answer key: the answer that scores is whatever most of your table writes. Some questions do have a clear favorite, though. Here is what most groups tend to say for ten Classic Herd Mentality questions. Treat it as a guide, not a rule, since your table may prove it wrong. Reading a few out is a quick way to show new players how the game works.

Classic questionLikely answer
Name a yellow food.Banana
Name a farm animal.Cow
Name a big cat.Lion
Name a color of the rainbow.Red
Pick a number from 1 to 10.7
Name a pizza topping.Pepperoni
Name a hot drink.Coffee
Name a topping for pancakes.Syrup
Name something in the night sky.The moon
Name a dip for chips.Salsa

Printing for a holiday party? The Christmas Herd Mentality questions have their own PDF, so you can print that pack alone. For a gift swap, every left right story prints from its list, and the Christmas trivia questions and answers print with the answer key on its own page. Christmas party games sorted by group puts them together into plans for an office, a family or a classroom.

Printable cards FAQ

Are there answers to these questions?
There is no official answer key, and these unofficial Herd Mentality cards hold only the questions. The answer that scores is whatever most of your table writes, so "Name a farm animal" might score cow in one group and pig in another. The table on this page shows what most groups tend to say for ten Classic questions, as a guide rather than a rule.
What is in the printable set?
Every question from all 8 packs, 507 in all, as cards that print eight to a page. After the cards come a score sheet with room for ten players and an Odd One Out card to cut out. Printed from this page, the set runs to about 70 pages. The PDF adds a contents and rules page, 71 in all.
Is there a Herd Mentality questions PDF?
Yes. This page has a free download of the same unofficial set as one PDF: 71 US Letter pages with all 507 questions as cards, the score sheet, the Odd One Out card and the paper rules on page 1. Page 1 also lists where each pack starts, so you can print only the packs you need. No sign-up is needed. There is no official answer key: the answer that scores is whatever most of your table writes.
Are there questions for kids in the PDF?
Yes. Print the Family pack, written for ages 6 and up, on pages 15–25 of the PDF. Classic, on pages 2–14, suits ages 10 and up. Thanksgiving, Christmas and Super Bowl suit all ages, and New Year’s Eve has a couple of midnight-toast questions to skip with young kids. Leave out the Adults pack, on pages 26–34, which is for ages 16 and up.
Can I print just one pack?
Yes. Open the pack from the question lists and use “Print this pack”. Its questions print as the same cards, with the pack name in the corner, which saves paper if you only want one set for the night. Or print just that pack’s pages from the PDF: page 1 lists where each pack starts.
Do I need the boxed game to use these cards?
No. The cards, the score sheet and the Odd One Out card are enough, plus pens and paper for answers. They are unofficial and do not come from the boxed game by Big Potato Games.