How to play: everyone holds a gift. Read the story out loud. Pass one seat left on every LEFT and one seat right on every RIGHT. When the story ends, keep what you're holding.
Every December, Carol and Phil Henderson throw an ugly sweater party, and the invitation has two rules. The sweater must be ugly. The sweater must be on your body. Three years ago a man tried to enter one on a hanger. He left in shame.
The prize is the Golden Cardigan, a thrift store cardigan Phil spray-painted in the garage. For six years it has gone home with Dennis from next door. Dennis does not buy his sweaters. Dennis builds them. He starts in July.
This year he arrived at seven sharp, and the room went quiet. On his left side was a stuffed reindeer with a blinking nose. On his right side was a second reindeer, staring at the first one, blinking back. The speaker was in his right sleeve, and every time he raised his right arm, it played eleven seconds of "Jingle Bells." He shook hands with everyone. It took a while.
Then Aunt Rosalie walked in, and nobody looked at Dennis anymore. Her sweater was knitted in 1987 by Aunt Dot, who had poor eyesight and would not be told. It was the color of a traffic cone that had received bad news. The snowman on the front had four arms. And it had two left sleeves. Not two sleeves on the left. Two left sleeves, one on each side. "Still fits," said Rosalie, drifting to the left, because the sweater would not let her go any other way.
Over in the good chair sat Grandpa Ed, in a brown sweater with a green zigzag and a mustard patch on the left elbow. People kept coming over. "What commitment," they said. "Where did you find that thing?" Grandpa Ed looked down. "Sears, in 1994," he said. "This is my good one." Nobody knew what to say, so they went right back to the snack table.
At eight o'clock, nine-year-old Maddie Henderson called the judging to order. She can't be bought, although several people have tried with fudge, and she has kept the fudge. The runway never changes: left at the couch, right at the coffee table, and right back to the stairs.
Dennis went first. Left at the couch. Right at the coffee table. Right arm up, "Jingle Bells." Left arm up, nothing, and he let that sink in. Somebody's uncle wept.
Then came Rosalie. She went left at the couch. She went left at the coffee table, which was wrong. She went left around Uncle Frank and left around the couch again, waving. "Turn right!" yelled Carol. "I'm trying!" yelled Rosalie. Nobody has ever turned right in that sweater, and that includes Aunt Dot.
On her third lap she came up on Dennis's right side. Aunt Dot had attached the snowman's buttons with Velcro, and Dennis's reindeer were very fuzzy. There was a small, happy sound. They were stuck. Dennis pulled right. Rosalie, who had no choice, pulled left. His right arm shot up, and this time "Jingle Bells" did not stop.
That was when Waffles the cat, who had been watching those noses all night, flew out from under the couch and landed on Rosalie's left sleeve. The one on the right. Everybody pulled left, then right, then left, and with a sound like the world's longest zipper, they all came apart.
Dennis kept the buttons. Rosalie kept a reindeer. Waffles kept a nose and ran upstairs with it, still blinking. "Jingle Bells" slowed down, dropped an octave, and quit right in the middle of "one-horse open sleigh."
Maddie looked left at Dennis. She looked right at Rosalie, who was still drifting. Then she walked right past them both and put the Golden Cardigan on Grandpa Ed. "His is the ugliest," she said, "and he didn't even try." Grandpa Ed looked at the gold paint on top of the brown zigzag. "Goes right with it," he said. He wore them both to church on Sunday.
Rosalie is knitting Dennis a sweater as a peace offering, and she has finished both sleeves. They're both left. So pass it left. Pass it right. Left again. Right again. Left, left, right, right. Whatever you're holding right now is yours. If it has two left sleeves, call Rosalie.
The Ugly Sweater Party Left Right Story · playcouchful.com/left-right-game/story/ugly-sweater-left-right/